Home
Search
עברית
Board & Mission Statement
Why IAM?
About Us
Articles by IAM Associates
On the Brighter Side
Ben-Gurion University
Hebrew University
University of Haifa
Tel Aviv University
Other Institutions
Boycott Calls Against Israel
Israelis in Non-Israeli Universities
Anti-Israel Petitions Supported by Israeli Academics
General Articles
Lawfare
Activists Profiles
Readers Forum
Photographs
Anti-Israel Conferences
Board of Advisers and Associates
How can I complain?
Contact Us / Subscribe
Donate
Number of visitors to IAM
Tel Aviv University
A letter from Edgar Pick, Professor emeritus at Tel Aviv University to Mark Tanenbaum, resigned TAU governor

May 24, 2010

Mr. Mark H. Tanenbaum

Miami Beach, Florida

Dear Mr. Tanenbaum

I am a Professor of Immunology at the Sackler School of Medicine, since 1970, when

I joined the academic staff of Tel Aviv University, following postdoctoral studies at the

Scripps Research Foundation in La Jolla and the University of London. I am

attaching a brief Curriculum Vitae.

The reason behind this letter are the recent events at Tel Aviv University, following

the speech by Mr. Dershowitz and your resignations from all your Tel Aviv Universityrelated

functions, after many years of serving this institution in more than one way.

Your letter of resignation of May 11, 2010, was made public and the tumultuous

events at the Board of Governors meeting have been aired in the press. Not having

been present at this event, my knowledge of what went on is based on what we

scientists would define as incomplete and possibly biased evidence. I do, however,

believe that your description of what happened, in your letter of resignation, is

accurate, meaning that the President of Tel Aviv University refused to allow a vote on

your very important proposed resolution. I understand that your resolution dealt with

the issue of some radical Tel Aviv University academics promoting a worldwide

boycott of our own university.

I shall state from the beginning that I would like to congratulate you on your

courageous stand at the Board of Governors meeting and after the meeting.

As someone who has been with Tel Aviv University for forty years, I am well familiar

with the intensive, unrelenting and extremist activities of a number of the members of

the academic staff of our University, who will not miss a single occasion to accuse

this country of the worst crimes, support the most extreme forms of academic boycott

against the Israeli academia, and offer support and encouragement to those whose

explicit purpose is the elimination of Israel, as the home of the Jewish people.

The purpose of this letter is not to reiterate what is known to all who are honest

enough to admit it, but to draw your attention to lesser known facts about the

unwillingness of the officials of Tel Aviv University to stand up to what became an

organized campaign of the vilification of Israel. Any attempt to put a halt to it is

countered by the argument that the “McCarthyites” are trying to suppress academic

freedom and free speech on the campus.

2

I would, thus, like to draw your attention to the more subtle ways by which Tel Aviv

University is condoning activities that endanger the very existence of the university

as an academic institution where the quality of research and teaching should be

valued more than political sympathies. I shall not bring up the well known names

mentioned by Alan Dershowitz but point out some of the events taking place on the

campus under the very eyes of the present and past Presidents and Rectors.

1.The university hosts the “Minerva Center for Human Rights”, financed by the

German Max Planck Society but receiving massive funding from political bodies such

as the Friedrich Ebert Foundation and the Adenauer Foundation, with matching by

Tel Aviv University. Among its scientific activities is a recent video conference with

participants from MIT and Harvard who support a dialogue with Hamas and with

special “guest star” Azmi Bishara. All my attempts to make the University aware of

the extremist political nature of such “research”, by writing to the present President

and the past Rector, were not considered worthy of an answer.

2.In 2009, a new “Minerva Center for the Humanities” was formed with a budget of 4

million Euro (!) to be matched by an equal sum (!) from Tel Aviv University. I am

attaching the official Tel Aviv University announcement. The directors of this glorious

Center are Professor Rivka Feldhay, a past collaborator of famed scientist Azmi

Bishara, Professor Adi Ophir, a leading organizer of Israel Apartheid Week (see

attached document) and Dr. Raif Zreik, a central figure in the intensely anti-Israeli

organization, Adalah.

3.I am sure that you must have noticed that past and present members of the

academic community of Tel Aviv University functioned exclusively as official political

representatives of the Israeli Left. These include: Itamar Rabinovich, Shlomo Ben-

Ami, Eli Bar-Navi, Yuli Tamir, Avi Primor, and Shimon Shamir, and I might have

missed some.

4. I am bringing up these examples not because I think that a University cannot have

a naturally developed political bias. A liberal, Left-leaning, and human rights-focused

orientation are common to most prominent academic institutions in both America and

Europe. The problem is that such orientation prevents them from taking action

against those extremists who work actively against the best interests of universities

and the academic endeavor, in general. This reluctance is justified by what they

define as the wish to conserve academic freedom and the freedom of expression on

the campus. The truth is that, independently of what party won the national elections,

your future at Tel Aviv University, in most departments in the fields of the Humanities,

Social Sciences, Law and the Arts, is dependent on you being looked upon as one

who is a member of the so called "peace camp" and who will distance him/herself

from the "settlers", the Likud, and the religious "extremists".

I know that you were upset by Klafter’s attitude. It will be of little consolation to you if I

tell you that the earlier Presidents were variations of the same. The only difference

that I sensed was that, when writing to Itamar Rabinovich or Zvi Galil, to protest yet

another anti-Israel event on the campus that included, as an example, the

participation of such an eminent scientist as Tali Fahima at a “Minerva Center for

Human Rights” conference, they would respond by a brief note stating that it is not in

their power to prevent it. I wrote to Klafter three times; once to ask for his support in

3

preventing the scientific boycott of Ariel College, the second time to condemn the

activities of two Tel Aviv University staff against the Israel science exhibit in Boston,

and the third time to ask him to prevent the Pro-Hamas conference at the Faculty of

Law. He never even acknowledged my letters. The sad thing is that even somebody

whom I considered a friend, such as Dany Leviatan, never ever did something to

prevent the gradual radicalization of Tel Aviv University.

5. An excellent example for the lack of courage and determination of Tel Aviv

University administrators is the fact that most of the most vicious enemies of the

State of Israel are constantly traveling from one disinvestment meeting to another

boycott meeting. These travels are financed by a special fund belonging to members

of the academic staff, but proof has to be presented that the travel is related to the

academic and/or research activities of the person. The Rector or Vice-Rector have to

approve the use of funds. In spite of the fact that the real purpose of the trips of these

"traveling salesmen of anti-Israel poison" is widely known, the Tel Aviv University

administration is too frightened to refuse the use of University funds for activities

intended to delegitimize the University and the State of Israel.

6. One should not accept blindly the claim that we are dealing with a tiny minority of

no real impact. As pointed out by Alan Dershowitz, we are not only facing vicious

attacks on our academia by a determined group but also systematic indoctrination of

students ex cathedra. My son in law is being taught by a Tel Aviv University historian

that the war of independence was, in fact, a “civil war” for disputed land fought by

Jewish Palestinians and Arab Palestinians.

7. It is also significant that about forty-six Tel Aviv University professors signed a

statement condemning the speech of Dershowitz and many opposed the very fact of

offering him a forum for the expression of his ideas. It became an accepted habit at

Tel Aviv University that the freedom of speech is the exclusive prerogative of those

who are the worst enemies of the freedom of expression.

8.One should, of course, ask, why this lack of courage and determination in fighting

evil and why the mentioned group of extremists can hold a whole University at

ransom. The answer lies with the international campaign of delegitimization of Israel

which has taken over most academic institutions all over the world. Most of the

academic staff of Tel Aviv University and of most institutions of higher learning in

Israel have learned that their chances of being invited to meetings, become members

of international committees, or merely be befriended by scientific colleagues abroad,

is made much easier if you are looked upon as an open-minded individual who is not

afraid to condemn and criticize Israel for the occupation of Palestinian land,

infringement of human rights, and crimes committed in Gaza. A perfect example for

this is the economist Menachem Yaari, the President of the Israel Academy of

Sciences, who will not miss one occasion to vilify this country and express sympathy

and support for the Palestinian cause. Thus, you can safely assume that Professor

Klafter will not jeopardize his future "jobs" by actions which will be considered by the

enlightened ruling class of the academia as limiting the freedom of expression. Far

from being "useful idiots", to use Stalin's expression, the defenders of extremism

know well on which side their bread is buttered.

4

9.There is, however, no better example for the abandonment by Tel Aviv University of

any intention to resist the growing threat from the hate campaigners than the event

recounted to me by my wife, who is the secretary of the Department of Archeology: At

the end of the yearly graduation ceremony, some of the Jewish academic staff

remained seated during the singing of the Hatikva, together with the Arab students

and their families. My wife approached the Dean of Humanities and asked him why

such outrage is accepted. He said that he did not notice that it happened. Neither did

the Rector feel that this behavior should be condemned in a statement by the Tel Aviv

University authorities. I would like to make it clear that, as a liberal intellectual, I

believe that people should not be forced to stand up at the singing of the National

Anthem. However, the Heads of Tel Aviv University should not behave as if it did not

happen and should, at least, express their disapproval of such an act.

Unfortunately, I have to conclude that people who lack intellectual honesty, national

pride, and courage to fight openly for what is good and honest should be punished at

the only level that they do understand: money.

I would like to congratulate you on your decision to stop all financial support to Tel

Aviv University. I hope that you can recruit other donors to direct their donations for

this University elsewhere, until the time that a new, honest and courageous

leadership takes over. In the dire financial state that they are in, they should be

taught a lesson. That playing Chamberlain to the threats from within the academia,

mentioned in the Dershowitz speech, comes with a negative price tag.

Once again, thanks for your honesty and courage. Many of us were waiting for a long

time for a Mr. Tanenbaum to appear on the scene.

With best regards,

Edgar Pick, M.D.,Ph.D.

Professor Emeritus

Julius Friedrich Cohnheim Laboratory of Phagocyte Research

Department of Clinical Microbiology and Immunology

Sackler School of Medicine

Tel Aviv University

Tel Aviv 69978

Israel

TEL: 972-3-640-7872

FAX: 972-3-642-9119

E-mail: epick@post.tau.ac.il

http://www2.tau.ac.il/Person/medicine/researcher.asp?id=ahheikije

Back to "Tel Aviv University"Send Response
Top Page
    Developed by Sitebank & Powered by Blueweb Internet Services
    Visitors: 81273624Send to FriendAdd To FavoritesMake It HomepagePrint version
    blueweb