Board & Mission Statement
Why IAM?
About Us
Articles by IAM Associates
Ben-Gurion University
Hebrew University
University of Haifa
Tel Aviv University
Other Institutions
Boycott Calls Against Israel
Israelis in Non-Israeli Universities
Anti-Israel Petitions Supported by Israeli Academics
General Articles
Anti-Israel Conferences
Anti-Israel Academic Resolutions
Lectures Interrupted
Activists Profiles
Readers Forum
On the Brighter Side
How can I complain?
Contact Us / Subscribe
Hebrew University
[Hebrew U, Law] Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian: We meet to commemorate the Nakba which was waged against our people and has not yet ended

Dr. Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian who received a grant of CAD 379800 to promote education for Palestinian women in Israel smears Israel.

 Shalhoub-Kevorkian webpage: http://law.huji.ac.il/eng/crim.asp?staff_id=85&cat=802


Feminist Organizations in Haifa Commemorate the Nakba (May 2010)

Feminist organizations in Haifa (the Gender Studies Program in Mada al-Carmel, Assiwar, Kayan, Muntada – The Arab Forum for Sexuality, Education and Health, Aswat and al-Fanar) commemorated the Nakba by holding a screening of the film Salt of this Sea at the al-Medan Theatre in Haifa. The event was opened by Dr. Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian, Director of the Gender Studies Program at Mada al-Carmel. Dr. Shalhoub-Kevorkian spoke about the case of Ameer Mahkoul and Dr. Omar Saeed, stating that, “We meet today to commemorate the Nakba, which was waged against our people and has not yet ended, just as the system of persecution, domination, and attempted silencing has not ended. For Ameer and Omar continue to be imprisoned by this state, reminding them and reminding us of the continuing Nakba, and of our unending efforts to reject and resist it.”

She further stated that the evening was intended to allow for an exchange of knowledge and remembrance. “We remember that it is women upon whom the role of preserving memory, identity, reality and work falls, in spite of exile and the physical disconnection from the land and the place.”

Following these opening words was a screening of the film Salt of this Sea, directed by Annemarie Jacir. The film tells the story of a young Palestinian woman called Soraya (Suheir Hammad) who was born in Brooklyn, New York and who decided to return to her homeland, Palestine.





Projects in Israel
Security Reasoning, Spatial Politics, Patriarchy and the Economic Rights of Palestinian Women in Israel

Project Number 105538Start Date 2009/02/15Program Area/Group SEP | WRC
Area Under Study Middle East and North Africa | Middle East | Israel
Project Type Research Project
Project Sub-Type Policy
Project Status Active
Administrative Unit Ottawa
Regional Office Area MERO
Responsible Officer Baksh, Rawwida
ODA Sector Women'S Equality Organisations & Institutions
Canadian Collaboration No
Duration (months) 36
Extension (months) 0
Planned Completion Date 2012/02/15
Total Funding 379800


Palestinian women and girls account for over half of the Arab population in Israel, which makes up approximately 17% of the Israeli population. Palestinian women and girls are marginalized on two fronts: as women in Arab society and as Palestinians in Israeli society. This situation affects the economic status of Palestinian women, as seen, for example, in the feminization of poverty, low female labour force participation and high female unemployment. This grant will allow MADA al-Carmel (the Arab Center for Applied Social Research) to undertake a comprehensive investigation of Palestinian women's economic situation in Israel, with particular focus on the policies and processes that affect their ability to obtain an education, find a job, start a business, and participate in the formal or informal economy. The research results will be used to inform an evidence-based policy dialogue on the economic status of Palestinian women. Building the capacity of junior Palestinian researchers to conduct research and engage in public policy dialogue will be an important aspect of this project.

Recipient Institution(s)

MADA AL-CARMEL Arab center for applied Social Research (R.A)
Street Address 51 Allenby Street | Haifa | Israel 31090
Mailing Address PO Box 9132 | Haifa | Israel 31090
Website http://www.mada-research.org
Institution Type Private - Not for Profit
Geographic Scope Regional
UN Organization No
Component Number 001
Research Status Active
Institution Country Israel
Researcher Name Nadera Shalhoub-Kevorkian
Researcher Name Nadim Rouhana



July 1, 2010

Arab-Israeli group takes Canadian agency to court over terminated funding

By Patrick Martin
From Thursday's Globe and Mail

International Development Research Centre is alleged to have cancelled grants under pressure from Israel

An Arab-Israeli research group is taking the International Development Research Centre to court, alleging the Canadian Crown corporation cut off funding to the group under pressure from the Israeli government.

Mada al-Carmel, a 10-year-old social research centre based in Haifa, conducts research into Israel's Arab minority. Two years ago, Mada received a pair of three-year grants from the IDRC to study the marginalization of women in Arab-Israeli society and the low level of political participation by Arab Israelis.

In March, the IDRC terminated the grants, worth almost $800,000, in their second year. The decision means a loss of 40 per cent of Mada's income and a serious blow to the organization's reputation and credibility.

There was no indication of poor performance by Mada. Indeed, a March 3 letter from the IDRC states: "We wish to emphasize that this termination is ... by no means a reflection on the quality of the work being done by your institution."

Nadim Rouhana, Mada's founding director and a professor at Tufts University in Boston, alleges that parties close to the Israeli government of Benjamin Netanyahu pressed the Canadian government and the IDRC to end support for Mada.

As a Canadian Crown corporation, the IDRC is funded by the federal government but is managed at arm's length in order to avoid any appearance of political interference.

IDRC president David Malone, a distinguished former Canadian diplomat, denies that outside pressure or government interference played a role in the decision to terminate Mada's grants.

"It was a management decision," Mr. Malone said. "Strictly internal."

The decision has led to a legal application by Mada al-Carmel against the IDRC to have the termination quashed for lack of cause. The case is being heard in Federal Court in Ottawa.

In a sworn affidavit, Mr. Malone states that the IDRC's mandate is to fund research in developing nations and that Israel, as a high-income country, is not considered a developing state. Therefore, he stated, he felt duty-bound to kill the contracts.

He acknowledges that the Mada grants were "first brought to my attention as the result of an inquiry by NGO Monitor, an Israeli advocacy group," in late January.

Shortly afterward, IDRC management received a communication from the office of the Minister of Foreign Affairs, Lawrence Cannon, also inquiring about Mada.

Mr. Malone launched an internal inquiry to determine what, if anything, NGO Monitor had written about Mada.

NGO Monitor has carried out numerous campaigns aimed at discrediting international organizations such as Human Rights Watch, the New Israel Fund (a predominantly Jewish group) and Israeli organizations such as B'tselem, a human rights group, that have criticized Israeli government policies.

It was NGO Monitor that last year informed critics of Rights and Democracy, another federally funded arm's length organization, as well as the Canadian church group KAIROS, about the groups' support for parties and forums critical of Israel. Subsequently, KAIROS lost a $7-million grant from the Canadian International Development Agency. During a period of turmoil that saw several board members and staff resign, Rights and Democracy ended its support for three organizations in Israel and the Palestinian territories.

All this has been part of a wider Israeli crackdown on NGOs. Diplomats and aid officials in Israel have recently complained about what one diplomat called an "all-out assault on legitimate human rights groups," being promoted by the Netanyahu government.

Israel is highly sensitive to non-governmental organizations - often funded by foreign governments - telling Israelis how to run their country.

The IDRC learned that NGO Monitor had reported scathingly about a poster it claimed Mada had produced. The poster depicts an Israeli soldier with his hand in front of a Palestinian woman's chest and the provocative caption: "The occupation penetrates her life everyday."

"Mada al-Carmel publishes crude posters with images of an Israeli soldier touching the breasts of an Arab woman," wrote NGO Monitor's president, Gerald Steinberg.

The poster, however, clearly does not depict the soldier touching the woman's breasts.

Furthermore, Mada didn't publish the poster. Another organization did. But NGO Monitor persisted in its criticism.

"Even if Mada is not responsible for the poster itself, it still is part of a whole network of organizations that accuse Israel of sexually abusing Arab women, and that's false," Mr. Steinberg said.

"No one [here] has accused Israel of sexually abusing Arab women," insisted Dr. Rouhana. The event the poster advertised, he insists, pointed out how the minority role of Arabs in Israel adds to the marginalization of Arab-Israeli women.

This is not the first time NGO Monitor has been criticized for overzealous attacks on organizations critical of Israeli policy.

Yossi Alpher, a former director of the Jaffee Center for Strategic Studies at Tel Aviv University, recently wrote: "It [NGO Monitor] seems dead set on eliminating human rights monitoring of Israel entirely and smearing anyone who supports this vital activity."

Following the IDRC's investigation, Mr. Malone wrote to Mr. Cannon that he planned to continue Mada's grants. A month later, however, Mr. Malone changed his mind.

It was revealed in court in mid-June that, two weeks before Mada got the pink slip, Mr. Malone met with the Israeli ambassador at the Israeli embassy in Ottawa.

When asked by Mada's lawyer if that meeting had anything to do with his decision to terminate Mada's contracts, Mr. Malone was prevented from answering by a lawyer for the Attorney-General of Canada, who warned he must not reveal the contents of any such embassy meeting as it relates to Canada's national security and international relations.

Mr. Malone cautions people from leaping to conclusions. "It remains tempting, clearly, to construct a conspiracy theory out of something I was not allowed to testify to by government policy," said Mr. Malone, who pointed out that he had earlier testified under oath that he received "no direction, directly or indirectly ... from any other party external to IDRC."

"David Malone's not the bad guy in this; he's a victim," an IDRC insider said. "I think he genuinely believed that unless he ended Mada's funding, the government would find a way to end IDRC's arm's length independence from government."

Mr. Steinberg denies that was ever his goal. "We didn't consciously go after Mada, and we certainly didn't lobby the Canadian government to end Mada's funding."

"We simply made an inquiry, and the fact that it apparently triggered an investigation and a decision to end Mada's funding is an internal Canadian matter."

"You have to appreciate the atmosphere in Ottawa when all this was happening," says Audrey Macklin, a professor of administrative law at the University of Toronto. "Everyone was abuzz about Rights and Democracy," she said, "and they already had seen funding taken from other aid organizations."

"I can believe that Malone acted out of fear of losing the organization's independence," she said. "But when you make decisions out of such fear, you've already lost your independence."


Back to "Hebrew University"Send Response
Top Page
    Developed by Sitebank & Powered by Blueweb Internet Services
    Visitors: 256987060Send to FriendAdd To FavoritesMake It HomepagePrint version