Home
Search
עברית
Board & Mission Statement
Why IAM?
About Us
Articles by IAM Associates
Ben-Gurion University
Hebrew University
University of Haifa
Tel Aviv University
Other Institutions
Boycott Calls Against Israel
Israelis in Non-Israeli Universities
Anti-Israel Petitions Supported by Israeli Academics
General Articles
Anti-Israel Conferences
Lawfare
Anti-Israel Academic Resolutions
Lectures Interrupted
Activists Profiles
Readers Forum
On the Brighter Side
How can I complain?
Contact Us / Subscribe
Donate
General Articles
Oberlin College Solution to Anti-Semitic Professor

29.08.16

Editorial Note

In March this year IAM reported the case of Joy Karega of Oberlin College who posted anti-Semitic messages on her Facebook page.  The assistant professor shared a graphic of an ISIS terrorist pulling off a mask of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu with a tattoo of Star of David. Shortly after the Charlie Hebdo shooting in Paris Karega wrote: “This ain’t even hard. They unleashed Mossad on France and it’s clear why.”  She added that Netanyahu went to the free-speech rally that took place in Paris “uninvited and of course he went even when he was asked by Pres. Hollande (France) not to come. Netanyahu wanted to bend Hollande and French governmental officials over one more time in public just in case the message wasn’t received via Massod [sic] and the ‘attacks’ they orchestrated in Paris.” In a following post in November 2015 Karega wrote that ISIS was not really Islamic, but “a CIA and Mossad operation, and there’s too much information out here for the general public not to know this.”

In a response to public uproar, Marvin Krislov, Oberlin College President wrote in March that "Oberlin College respects the rights of its faculty, students, staff and alumni to express their personal views. Acknowledgement of this right does not signal institutional support for, or endorsement of, any specific position. The statements posted on social media by Dr. Joy Karega, assistant professor of rhetoric and composition, are hers alone and do not represent the views of Oberlin College".

However, recently Oberlin College has announced that Karega is being placed on a paid leave.  A statement by the College explained: “In March, in consultation with President Marvin Krislov, the trustees of Oberlin College asked the administration and faculty to ‘challenge the assertion that there is any justification for these repugnant postings’... The college initiated its faculty governance process to review Dr. Karega’s professional fitness in light of these postings. The faculty governance process that began thereafter is ongoing, and the Oberlin administration will continue to respect this process as it plays out. Until that process is complete, Dr. Karega has been placed on paid leave and will not teach at Oberlin.”

The dramatic change in tone (and action) in the Karega case is related to the public outrage created by her statements and anxiety of the administration over the possible reaction of donors and alumni.  In a similar case the President of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, acting under pressure from the Board of Trustees, rescinded the job offer to Steven Salaita because of anti-Semitic posts on social media.  IAM reported at the time that the Salaita affair posed an important First Amendment test case. IAM would follow the Karega case as it develops.






Oberlin places assistant professor on paid leave after anti-Semitic posts
KRISTEN MOTT | STAFF REPORTER 
kmott@cjn.org  Aug 3, 2016  (13)
Joy Karega, an assistant professor of rhetoric and composition at Oberlin College accused of making anti-Semitic posts and comments online, has been suspended from teaching at the school and placed on paid leave while an investigation into her actions continues.

The Oberlin College board of trustees asked the school to launch an internal investigation into Karega in March, and that process is ongoing, according to an Aug. 3 statement from the private liberal arts college, about 40 miles southwest of Cleveland.

“In March, in consultation with President Marvin Krislov, the trustees of Oberlin College asked the administration and faculty to ‘challenge the assertion that there is any justification for these repugnant postings,’” the statement said. “The college initiated its faculty governance process to review Dr. Karega’s professional fitness in light of these postings.

“The faculty governance process that began thereafter is ongoing, and the Oberlin administration will continue to respect this process as it plays out. Until that process is complete, Dr. Karega has been placed on paid leave and will not teach at Oberlin.”

Karega, whose full name is Joilynn Karega-Mason, could not be reached for comment. But she posted this on her Facebook page the morning of Aug. 3:

“I will continue to receive letters and notes of support here in my messages inbox and via email. I will read them. Trolls and those of you who have been surveiling my Facebook account since March, keep on keepin on, but I have NO COMMENT. I am more than blessed and grateful to have people adequately prepared, equipped, and more knowledgeable than me working on my behalf.”

In a joint statement from the Jewish Federation of Cleveland, the Anti-Defamation League Cleveland Region, AJC Cleveland and the Cleveland Hillel Foundation issued Aug. 3, the organizations stated: “We appreciate and respect Oberlin College’s decision to remove professor Joy Karega from teaching and student advising duties while the administrative review process continues. This interim decision sends an important message about the college’s commitment to seeing that academic freedom is not abused to the detriment of the students.

“The Jewish Federation of Cleveland, the Cleveland Hillel Foundation, AJC Cleveland and the Anti-Defamation League Cleveland region look forward to working with the college in the coming semester to foster a campus climate of openness, acceptance, tolerance and mutual respect where students can learn and thrive.”

Those same organizations met with Krislov and several members of his senior staff March 3 to discuss Karega and the posts in question.

In a March 5 statement, Clyde McGregor, chair of the Oberlin College board of trustees, condemned Karega’s comments, saying, “We deplore all forms of bigotry. They have no place at Oberlin.”

On Aug. 2, the Algemeiner, an online news portal for Jewish and Israel news, reported that an Oberlin alumni group had questioned why the administration hadn’t yet taken action against Karega for her Facebook posts.

In these since-deleted posts on her personal Facebook page, Karega shared comments, blog posts and videos that some have deemed anti-Semitic.

One week after the Charlie Hebdo shooting on Jan.7, 2015, for instance, Karega shared an image of an ISIS terrorist pulling off a mask resembling Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The terrorist had a tattoo on his forearm of the Star of David with the words “JSIL Israel.” The text on the photo read, “France wants to free Palestine? Time for a false flag …”

Karega’s post that accompanied the image read in part, “Folks who turn off the indoctrinated media and do their homework know where Charlie Hebdo receives its support and backing. And for a prime example of these workings? Try generating a similar kind of satire attacking Zionism. I dare you.

“And I didn’t say attacking Jews. I said attacking Zionism. But let some tell it, an attack on Zionism is an attack on Jews. It’s anti-Semitic, so they say. Total nonsense.”

On Nov. 17, 2015, Karega wrote on Facebook, “It’s troubling that in this day and age, when there is all this access to information, most of the public doesn’t know who and what ISIS really is. I promise you, ISIS is not a jihadist, Islamic terrorist organization. It’s a CIA and Mossad operation, and there’s too much information out here for the general public not to know this.”

And on March 7, 2015, Karega shared a blog post and video from a website called “Muslims for 9/11 Truth.” In her own post, Karega wrote that she’s not a fan of Louis Farrakhan, leader of the religious movement Nation of Islam, but that “politically, Farrakhan is truth-telling in this video.”

In the video she references, Farrakhan states, “Thanks to the exemplary work of scholars like Victor Thorn and Christopher Bollyn it is now becoming apparent that there were many Israeli and Zionist Jews in key roles in the 9/11 attack.”

Oberlin alumni were outraged that Karega continued to teach at the college, as was Anita Gray, regional director of the Anti-Defamation League, though Gray noted she supports Karega’s rights to free speech under the First Amendment.

On Aug. 3, Gray said by email, “It is my understanding that Oberlin College has removed Professor Karega from all teaching and advising duties while their process of review continues. I think it is entirely appropriate until the matter is finished, which it is not quite yet.  The ADL will be conducting campus anti-bias programming this fall.”

 Mark Jaffee, a longtime Oberlin resident, 1967 Oberlin College alumnus and religious director of Agudath B’nai Israel Synagogue in Lorain, said in an email, “I agree with the college that even though this process is taking a lot longer than most people would like, the results will affect more than just this one professor; it will set a protocol of the limits of academic freedom that will affect professors for years to come.”

“A faculty committee met last spring and will make its findings known this fall,” he continued. “The issues that they had to consider were that professor Karega’s postings were inflammatory and blatantly anti-Semitic, but the principle of academic freedom is that a faculty member can make false, obnoxious and abhorrent statements outside of their professional area, but professionally one is judged on the quality of one’s research and teaching.” 

Staff Reporter Carlo Wolff contributed to this story.





Oberlin Professor Accused of Anti-Semitic Remarks Is Placed on Paid Leave
By KATIE ROGERS
AUG. 3, 2016

A professor at Oberlin College who made a series of Facebook posts that suggested that Israeli and United States intelligence services were behind terror attacks has been placed on paid leave while the college continues to review the case, the college said Wednesday.

In a statement from Scott Wargo, the director of media relations for Oberlin, the college said that it had been “considering carefully the grave issues surrounding the anti-Semitic postings on social media by Oberlin faculty member Dr. Joy Karega.”

The statement continued: “The faculty governance process that began thereafter is ongoing, and the Oberlin administration will continue to respect this process as it plays out. Until that process is complete, Dr. Karega has been placed on paid leave and will not teach at Oberlin.”

In February, the news site The Tower published the posts made by Dr. Karega, an assistant professor who teaches rhetoric and composition, most dated back to early 2015. The private liberal arts school in Ohio at first defended its faculty members’ rights to express personal views, but in March, Clyde S. McGregor, the board chairman, wrote in a statement on behalf of the college’s board of trustees that “these grave issues must be considered expeditiously.”

That statement also described the posts Dr. Karega made as “anti-Semitic and abhorrent.” In her posts, Dr. Karega suggested that the Islamic State was funded by the C.I.A. and the Mossad organization, the Israeli intelligence service, and that Mossad was behind the Charlie Hebdo shootings in Paris.

In another post, she wrote, “it seems obvious that the same people behind the massacre in Gaza are behind the shooting down” of a Malaysia Airlines plane in 2014. An inquiry in 2015 concluded that the aircraft was likely hit by a Russian-made missile.

Mr. Wargo did not say when Dr. Karega had been placed on leave. Dr. Karega did not immediately respond to an email request for comment on Wednesday.

The president of the college, Marvin Krislov, told alumni in an email message on Wednesday that he was “committed to continuing and completing an equitable review process.”

On Facebook, Dr. Karega seemed to respond: “Equitable?” she wrote on Wednesday, before adding that she had no comment and was on vacation with her daughter.

On Wednesday evening, Dr. Karega shared a statement written on her behalf by Chui Karega, an attorney based in Detroit. The statement accused Oberlin of “pandering to the dictates of a handful of vocal and wealthy religious zealots.”

The statement continued: “It is truly regrettable that an institution such as Oberlin College, with a historical legacy of activism and social justice, particularly in terms of African Americans, is being used as a personal tool of religious extremism by a small number of people.”




Back to "General Articles"Send Response
Top Page
    Developed by Sitebank & Powered by Blueweb Internet Services
    Visitors: 241633730Send to FriendAdd To FavoritesMake It HomepagePrint version
    blueweb